The short answer
Want slow speeds and a two-hand grip? Makita
Want a simple palm sander? DeWalt
Both are 3 A corded 5 in random orbit sanders with hook-and-loop pads that top out at 12,000 orbits per minute. The Makita BO5041 goes down to 4,000 OPM and has an adjustable front handle. The DeWalt DWE6423 is a low-profile palm sander with a counterweight against vibration.
Best for control and slow work

Pick the Makita BO5041 if
- You want slow speeds: down to 4,000 OPM for finishes and edges.
- You want a front handle for two-hand control on big panels.
- You want through-the-pad dust collection with a bag and a vacuum nozzle in the box.
Best for one-hand palm sanding
Pick the DeWalt DWE6423 if
- You want a low-profile palm grip with a rubber overmold.
- You want a one-handed locking dust bag.
- You want DeWalt’s 3-year warranty with 1 year of free service.
Before you buy: Both listings were sold by Amazon when checked on Oct 16, 2026. Check the seller and that the item is new before you order.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Which is better at what
spec rows won
spec rows won
unclear
This counts the rows below where one is clearly better. It’s a tally, not a rating.
Makita wins 2: speed range and handle. The rest are even. A green check means a gap of more than 5% or a feature only one has. Every figure comes from the makers, not Amazon.
| Makita BO5041 | DeWalt DWE6423 | |
|---|---|---|
| Motor | 3 A, corded | 3 A, corded |
| Speed | 4,000-12,000 OPM, variable | 8,000-12,000 OPM, variable |
| Pad | 5 in, 8-hole hook-and-loop | 5 in, 8-hole hook-and-loop |
| Handle | Palm grip plus adjustable front handle | Low-profile palm grip |
| Vibration control | Pad control system | Counterweight |
| Dust | Through-the-pad, dust bag and nozzle | Locking dust bag, vacuum port |
Spec notes
- Weight is left out. Makita lists 3.1 lb on makitatools.com but 3.5 lb on a retail sheet, so the comparison with the DeWalt’s 3.4 lb isn’t solid.
- Orbit size is left out because DeWalt’s page doesn’t list one.
- Warranty is left out of the chart. DeWalt lists 3-yr limited, 1-yr free service, 90-day.
The verdict
The Makita BO5041 wins 2 rows to 0 and is the pick: the wider speed range and front handle give more control on big panels and finish work. Pick the DeWalt DWE6423 if you sand one-handed most of the time and like a compact palm grip.
Get the DeWalt DWE6423
Check the DeWalt DWE6423 on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Skip it if
Skip the DeWalt DWE6423
Skip it if you need slow speeds: it starts at 8,000 OPM, while the Makita goes down to 4,000 OPM. Skip it too if you want a front handle for two-hand control. It’s a palm grip only. Source: DeWalt, Makita.
Skip the Makita BO5041
Skip it if you already own a DeWalt extractor and want a direct fit. DeWalt says the DWE6423 port fits the DWV010 and DWV012, with the DWV9000 adapter for 1-1/4 in hoses. Source: DeWalt.
Questions about this pair
Which one handles slow, careful sanding better?
The Makita. It runs 4,000-12,000 OPM. The DeWalt runs 8,000-12,000 OPM, so its slowest setting is twice as fast. Source: Makita, DeWalt.
Which is easier to control on big panels?
The Makita has an adjustable front handle for two-hand use. The DeWalt is a low-profile palm sander with a separate counterweight against vibration. Source: Makita, DeWalt.
How does each one collect dust?
The Makita collects through the pad and comes with a dust bag, a nozzle and a built-in vacuum port adapter. The DeWalt has a one-handed locking dust bag, and its port fits DeWalt’s DWV010 and DWV012 extractors (DWV9000 adapter for 1-1/4 in hoses). Source: Makita, DeWalt.
Do they take the same sanding discs?
Yes. Both take 5 in, 8-hole hook-and-loop discs. Source: Makita, DeWalt.
Are they the same power?
Yes. Both are 3 A corded sanders that top out at 12,000 OPM. Source: Makita, DeWalt.
What warranty does the DeWalt have?
A 3-year limited warranty, 1 year of free service and a 90-day satisfaction guarantee. DeWalt also lists a dust-sealed switch. Source: DeWalt.