ShopwoodPlans

5 in random orbit sanders · Comparison

DeWalt DWE6423 vs Makita BO5041 sander

The short answer

Want slow speeds and a two-hand grip? Makita

Want a simple palm sander? DeWalt

Both are 3 A corded 5 in random orbit sanders with hook-and-loop pads that top out at 12,000 orbits per minute. The Makita BO5041 goes down to 4,000 OPM and has an adjustable front handle. The DeWalt DWE6423 is a low-profile palm sander with a counterweight against vibration.

Best for control and slow work

Makita BO5041 5 in random orbit sander on a wood panel, hooked up to a vacuum hose
Shown hooked up to a vacuum hose. Photo: “Makita BO5041 Random Orbit Sander” by Mark Hunter (Toolstop), via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Resized.

Pick the Makita BO5041 if

Full Makita BO5041 review

  • You want slow speeds: down to 4,000 OPM for finishes and edges.
  • You want a front handle for two-hand control on big panels.
  • You want through-the-pad dust collection with a bag and a vacuum nozzle in the box.
Check the Makita BO5041 on Amazon

Best for one-hand palm sanding

Pick the DeWalt DWE6423 if

Full DeWalt DWE6423 review

  • You want a low-profile palm grip with a rubber overmold.
  • You want a one-handed locking dust bag.
  • You want DeWalt’s 3-year warranty with 1 year of free service.
Check the DeWalt DWE6423 on Amazon

Before you buy: Both listings were sold by Amazon when checked on Oct 16, 2026. Check the seller and that the item is new before you order.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Which is better at what

2Makita BO5041
spec rows won
0DeWalt DWE6423
spec rows won
4even or
unclear

This counts the rows below where one is clearly better. It’s a tally, not a rating.

Makita wins 2: speed range and handle. The rest are even. A green check means a gap of more than 5% or a feature only one has. Every figure comes from the makers, not Amazon.

Makita BO5041DeWalt DWE6423
Motor3 A, corded3 A, corded
Speed4,000-12,000 OPM, variable8,000-12,000 OPM, variable
Pad5 in, 8-hole hook-and-loop5 in, 8-hole hook-and-loop
HandlePalm grip plus adjustable front handleLow-profile palm grip
Vibration controlPad control systemCounterweight
DustThrough-the-pad, dust bag and nozzleLocking dust bag, vacuum port
Spec notes
  • Weight is left out. Makita lists 3.1 lb on makitatools.com but 3.5 lb on a retail sheet, so the comparison with the DeWalt’s 3.4 lb isn’t solid.
  • Orbit size is left out because DeWalt’s page doesn’t list one.
  • Warranty is left out of the chart. DeWalt lists 3-yr limited, 1-yr free service, 90-day.

The verdict

The Makita BO5041 wins 2 rows to 0 and is the pick: the wider speed range and front handle give more control on big panels and finish work. Pick the DeWalt DWE6423 if you sand one-handed most of the time and like a compact palm grip.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Skip it if

Skip the DeWalt DWE6423

Skip it if you need slow speeds: it starts at 8,000 OPM, while the Makita goes down to 4,000 OPM. Skip it too if you want a front handle for two-hand control. It’s a palm grip only. Source: DeWalt, Makita.

Skip the Makita BO5041

Skip it if you already own a DeWalt extractor and want a direct fit. DeWalt says the DWE6423 port fits the DWV010 and DWV012, with the DWV9000 adapter for 1-1/4 in hoses. Source: DeWalt.

Questions about this pair

Which one handles slow, careful sanding better?

The Makita. It runs 4,000-12,000 OPM. The DeWalt runs 8,000-12,000 OPM, so its slowest setting is twice as fast. Source: Makita, DeWalt.

Which is easier to control on big panels?

The Makita has an adjustable front handle for two-hand use. The DeWalt is a low-profile palm sander with a separate counterweight against vibration. Source: Makita, DeWalt.

How does each one collect dust?

The Makita collects through the pad and comes with a dust bag, a nozzle and a built-in vacuum port adapter. The DeWalt has a one-handed locking dust bag, and its port fits DeWalt’s DWV010 and DWV012 extractors (DWV9000 adapter for 1-1/4 in hoses). Source: Makita, DeWalt.

Do they take the same sanding discs?

Yes. Both take 5 in, 8-hole hook-and-loop discs. Source: Makita, DeWalt.

Are they the same power?

Yes. Both are 3 A corded sanders that top out at 12,000 OPM. Source: Makita, DeWalt.

What warranty does the DeWalt have?

A 3-year limited warranty, 1 year of free service and a 90-day satisfaction guarantee. DeWalt also lists a dust-sealed switch. Source: DeWalt.

By Mike E. · Specs checked November 3, 2026 · Based on manufacturer specs. Not tested hands-on.